Not All Medicine is Sweet: The Case for Dark Medicine as Self-Care

We’ve been trained to believe healing should feel cozy and good. Transformation must be wrapped in softness and sweetness:

Gratitude lists

Bubble baths

Soothing affirmations

We think that if it stings, if it tastes bitter, if it feels confrontational, it can’t possibly be healing.

That’s a lie.

Throughout history, medicine has rarely been sweet

The first antibiotics burned the veins (they often still do when given intravenously). 

Most pills tasted like misery solidified.

Even traditional herbal remedies were bitter, hard to swallow. 

Rituals of purification and cleansing, too. Think fasting, sweat lodges, and bitter teas.  The cure didn’t feel comfortable. 

The same applies to dark medicine as self-care.

I call this dark medicine because we’ve popularized sweet or neutral medicine as a way to minimize discomfort. That may work in the medical field, but in self-care, we sometimes need to get uneasy before we get healed. .

Dark medicine is the kind of healing we resist, the kind that asks us to face what we’d rather bury. It is the work of confrontation, not escape. 

It’s the path of bitter truths, shadow integration, the naming of the unnamable.

And here’s the paradox: 

Though dark medicine is the hardest to take, it is often the only thing that makes us whole.

Soft, soothing self-care has its place. But we can’t ignore the bitter stuff. The bitter medicine is the type of self-care we avoid. But solely chasing sweetness is avoidance, not true self-compassion.

The Core Philosophy

Dark medicine rests on three principles:

1. Extraction.
   Healing often requires ferreting out the poison, pulling something toxic out of hiding  (grief, rage, exhaustion, guilt, secrets). Extraction hurts. But leaving the poison inside is worse..
2. Exposure to air
   Dark medicine shines a light on what festers in shadow. Naming the unspeakable breaks its hold. If you can write it, you can see it. If you can see it, you can begin to live with it honestly.
3. Integration.
   The goal isn’t to banish darkness, but to weave it into wholeness. Dark medicine teaches: you are not broken because you rage, or weep, or long to run away. You are whole because you carry the full spectrum of human experience.
   

Why Dark Matters

Calling it dark is deliberate.
We live in a culture obsessed with light 

Positivity 

Optimism 

Productivity. 

Light is easy to market and darkness is harder to sell. But ignoring the dark has consequences: suppressed emotions, unspoken truths, burnout, silence.

Dark medicine honors what is raw, gritty, unfiltered. It doesn’t apologize for being hard to take. It reminds us that truth is rarely sweet, but it always heals.

It is also through darkness that light is born. From the womb to the ocean, darkness is not to be feared, but respected and explored. The darkness is the core, pulsing with the strongest energy we can harness for self-care, self-love.

The Villain Era Connection

In every story, the villain sees what the hero denies. The villain names truths the world doesn’t want to face. Often, the villain is not wrong. They’re just braver and more committed to their goal. They’re willing to say aloud what no one else will. And they’re willing to take the most uncomfortable action, despite others’ judgement and scrutiny. 

Dark medicine carries that same energy. It appears villainous not because it harms, but because it refuses to coddle. It refuses to lie.

And in that refusal, it sets you free.

A Framework for Practice

Dark medicine can take many forms, but the framework is simple:

• Identify the poison. What unspoken truth, what festering resentment, what unacknowledged grief is keeping you sick/stuck/self-abandoning?
• Take the dose. Face it directly. Write it, speak it, ritualize it. Allow yourself to feel the sting.
• Close the ritual. Seal the dose. Burn the page. Fold the journal (I suggest doing this with a Dark Medicine Journalette). Whisper the truth into the air.
• Integrate. Walk with the lesson, not the wound. Let it change you.

Dark medicine is not comfortable. It is not soothing. It is not meant to make you feel better in the moment. But…

…it will be a step towards wholeness..

The truth doesn’t care if you’re comfortable. The truth only cares if you’re free.

Share This: